We've tried our hand at love before
 We've been around the game enough to know the score
 But then is then, and now is now
 And now is all that matters anyhow
 Make believe it's your first time
 Leave your sadness behind
 Make believe it's your first time
 And I'll make believe it's mine
 The door is closed, it's you and me
 We'll take our time with love the way it ought to be
 This moment's ours, tonight's the night
 And if we fall in love, that's all right
 Make believe it's your first time
 Leave your sadness behind
 Make believe it's your first time
 And I'll make believe it's mine
 Make believe it's your first time
 And I'll make believe it's mine