作词 : Joel Ferber/Callie Sullivan
 Gotta get my coat now
 'Cause it's said it's time to go
 Tryin' to be careful with you
 But I'm starting to feel alone
 Only when it's cold out
 Do I want someone to hold
 Think that it's too soon to look back
 But I'll drive away real slow

 Thought I knew better
 But I was scared
 I had reasons
 But they're not here now

 I should've I should've stayed
 I think I made a mistake
 Now I'm just chasing
 The one I pushed away
 One I pushed away
 'Cause I couldn't
 I couldn't wait for us
 To fix the mess I made
 Now I'm just chasing
 The one that got away
 One that got away
 I should've
 I should've stayed

 Late at night I wonder
 If it's just as hard for you
 Won't delete your number
 No-no
 So when you call
 It still goes through

 Thought I knew better
 But I was scared
 I had reasons
 But they're not here now

 I should've
 I should've stayed
 I think I made a mistake
 Now I'm just chasing
 The one I pushed away
 One I pushed away
 'Cause I couldn't
 I couldn't wait for us
 To fix the mess I made
 Now I'm just chasing
 The one that got away
 One that got away
 I should've
 I should've
 Stayed

 I should've
 I should've
 Stayed
 I should've
 I should've
 Stayed
 I should've
 I should've
 Stayed
 I should've
 I should've
 Stayed
 I should've
 I should've
 I should've
 I should've
 I should've
 I should've
 I should've
 I should've
 Stayed
 I should've stayed
 I should've stayed
 I should've stayed
 Stayed, stayed, stayed