Hilary Duff - Who's That Girl Album: Hilary Duff There were places we would go at midnight There were secrets that nobody else would know-ow There's a reason but I don't know why I don't know why, I don't know why. I thought they all belong to me Who's that girl, where's she from No she can't be the one that you want That has stolen my world It's not real, it's not right It's not day, it's not night By the way, who's that girl Livin' my life Oh no, livin' my life Seems like everything's the same, around me Then I look again and everything is changed I'm not dreaming so I don't know why, I don't know why I don't know why, she's everywhere I wanna be No she can't be the one, that you want I'm the one who made you laugh, I made you feel, I made you sad I'm not sorry, for what we did, for who we were I'm not sorry I'm not her